News Release 3/13/02 16:14
Bloomberg.com: Airline Bonds Top `100 Worst Trades' List: Joe Mysak
New York, Oct. 17 (Bloomberg) -- Tax-exempt bond issues sold
by airlines dominate the ``100 Worst Trades'' compiled by
quarterly MunicipalBonds.com.
The list, covering the third quarter of this year, spotlights
transactions where the price disparity on a single day of trading
exceeded 9 1/2 points. Topping the list were bonds sold in 1999 by
Chicago's O'Hare International Airport for United Airlines. In
July, some of the bonds were sold to a customer at 100 cents on
the dollar. The same bonds were purchased from a customer for a
little over 29 cents on the dollar.
This is the fifth time Kevin Olson, a former bond salesman in
San Francisco, has put together a ``worst trades'' list on his web
site. He put out the list for the first two quarters of this year
and for all of 2000 and 2001.
Olson, an advocate for fair pricing in the municipal market,
last month declared war on the bond industry with a lawsuit
alleging that dealers routinely charge customers too much to buy
and sell their securities. Olson envisions a role for his website
as a central repository for pricing and other information. To be
sure, he already has a lock on a whale of a domain name.
Lawsuit aside, municipal bond dealers don't have much use for
the MunicipalBonds.com website because they say it makes them look
like a bunch of crooks. They say most transactions in the
municipal market don't feature big markups or markdowns. They
don't typically sell bonds for 103, and buy the same bonds for a
price of 55 cents on the dollar. Red-flagging atypical trades is
unfair, they say.
Cautionary Tales
And yet Olson's not making this stuff up. His tallies are
based on trades listed every day by the Municipal Securities
Rulemaking Board and available on the Bloomberg and on the
MunicipalBonds.com and InvestinginBonds.com websites.
Olson red-flags transactions that show a price disparity
bigger than four points, and he usually comes up with a list of 20
to 40 of them from the thousands of daily trades.
Olson's lists, both daily and quarterly, showcase a variety
of cautionary tales demonstrating what might be described kindly
as instances of excessive wholesale and retail pricing -- as well
as some simple mistakes in transaction reporting. Did someone
really sell their bonds for 65 cents on the dollar? Or did a clerk
type a ``6'' instead of a ``9''?
All this is the legacy of a market that for years lived the
unexamined life. There was no price information available to the
public, there were and remain no standards for markups, and
dealers dictated all the terms. Prices were what brokers said they
were. Is it any wonder there were some abuses?
The current system of price reporting was only put in place
in the mid-1990s after Arthur Levitt was named chairman of the
Securities and Exchange Commission. Levitt, who is now a director
of Bloomberg LP, parent of Bloomberg News, demanded that dealers
disclose their markups on so-called ``riskless principal
transactions'' where they buy bonds specifically to sell to a
customer. That refusal spoke volumes.
So does the current system, in its way. Those stories are
told succinctly on the MunicipalBonds.com website.
No Surprise
This time around, instead of a freak show featuring the usual
unrated and high-yield junk bonds, we have a theme: The swift
collapse of the U.S. airline industry in the wake of the September
11 terrorist attacks on New York and Washington.
Airline or airport bonds are listed as 26 of the ``worst
trades.'' Airlines usually have to sell taxable debt when they
want to do things like build planes. They can sell tax-exempt
bonds through airports to build hangars and gates.
Called ``special facilities'' bonds, there are about $14
billion of these kinds of securities out of the $74 billion in
bonds sold by airports altogether, according to Mark Doyle of
Sterling Grace Municipal Securities in Spotswood, New Jersey, who
specializes in high-yield municipal bonds.
That airline bonds dominate the MunicipalBonds.com list this
quarter isn't surprising. The airline industry hasn't been the
same since September 11, which shut down the nation's airways for
three days last year. Air travel dropped 22 percent after the
attacks to the end of the year. So far this year, it's off by 6.2
percent over the same period last year.
Airline bonds had been trading at a discount all this year.
They plunged after US Airways Group filed for bankruptcy on Aug.
11, and United Airlines said it was considering bankruptcy.
That's why in this list bonds sold by American Airlines,
Delta and Continental are shown trading at prices all over the
lot, from 30 cents through more than 100 cents on the dollar.
Nobody really knows what they're worth. Some bondholders are so
eager to be rid of them that they will sell them at any price. The
buyers must be calculating the odds of bankruptcy.
This is logical. This makes sense, something not always on
display in municipal market trading as depicted in the
MunicipalBonds.com lists.
Check Data
Rounding out the ``worst trades'' list are 19 bonds sold for
hospital or health care facilities, which is down from the 29 in
the second quarter report, and six multifamily housing
transactions.
There are industrial development bonds sold for paper
companies, one for a skating rink, and another for a Tennessee
boat builder. There are college savings bonds, sewer improvement
bonds, turnpike revenue bonds, and even a few pretty
straightforward general obligations.
As the latest list shows, sometimes there are some good
reasons for wide price disparities. Sometimes there aren't.
How can bond buyers protect themselves? A good start would be
by looking up bonds they want to buy and see how they've been
trading. That's about as simple as it gets. If your broker
objects, maybe it's time to look for a new broker.
|