Municipal Bonds Q&A With James Colby


December 12, 2012

By:

The current ultra-low rate environment has prompted investors of all styles to scour the markets for meaningful sources of yield without incurring handfuls of volatility. Looming economic uncertainties all over the globe have made it even more challenging for investors looking to tame their portfolio's volatility while generating income at the same time. One particular breed of fixed income securities, however, warrants a closer look from income-hungry investors: enter municipal bonds. James Colby, portfolio manager and senior municipal strategist at Market Vectors ETFs in New York, recently took time out of his schedule to discuss the state the muni bond market, as well as offer insights into how ETFs offer a compelling way to access this asset class.

Municipal Bonds (MB): What would you consider to be the most compelling characteristics of municipal bonds amid the current low-rate environment?

James Colby (JC): In addition to their low volatility, municipal bonds have continued to deliver yield on a taxable equivalent basis higher than that of most other asset classes. Only recently has the ratio of muni yields (AAA quality) to Treasury yields dipped below 100%. Total return for investment grade municipals (Barclays Municipal Bond Index) is 6.36%, and 15.78% for municipal high yield (Barclays Muni High Yield Index) through October 31, 2012. Despite downgrades, the credit quality for the broad market, covering as many as 60,000 issuers, is still in the range of AA.

MB: There have been a few pundits saying that they expect a wave of municipal bond defaults in the not-so-distant future. How do you respond to those predictions?

JC: Clearly investors have responded to those assertions by pouring nearly $50 billion (year-to-date) into municipal funds and ETFs, demonstrating their renewed confidence in the resilience of this asset class. While the notion that there would be strains brought upon the budgets of municipalities is accurate, the prediction of waves of defaults was reckless and not based upon a clear understanding of how default/bankruptcy differs for municipalities as opposed to corporates.

MB: What have default rates been historically? What typically happens in the event of default?

JC: Municipal default rates have historically been less than half of that of the corporate high-yield market. Municipal bankruptcies by all accounts average 3-5% in studies done by ratings agencies. Those credit impairments have, in fact, been on the decline during the past two years. When an impairment occurs, often a restructuring results, which historically allows bondholders to recover as much as 70%, as to principal and interest; far higher than in the corporate marketplace.

MB: What are the benefits associated with accessing municipal bonds through the ETF wrapper? What are some potential drawbacks?

JC: The benefits from an ETF wrapper are several. Whereas the cost of buying or selling a bond can be significant and unclear, the cost of accessing tax-free income from an ETF is visible in the spread of the quoted stock and the much lower management fee charged, compared to mutual funds. Further, the investor is not limited to how much cash to invest compared to the $5,000 minimum required for individual bonds. And the ETF is broadly diversified, which means that the investor is insulated from sudden illiquidity or credit concerns associated with individual holdings. Finally, dividends are tax-free and are delivered monthly as opposed to semi-annual coupon payments from bonds.

MB: How would a worst-case scenario outcome regarding the "fiscal cliff" potentially affect municipal bonds?

JC: It is difficult to assess the worst-case scenario, but if the benefit of tax-free income is capped at some rate say 28% - then municipal rates would have to rise to compensate holders for that portion being taxed. That rise in rates flows immediately to the issuers, increasing their cost of capital. And, instead of just taxing the wealthy, the higher cost of capital is then passed on to all taxpayers of those communities. Thus, everyone then pays what I call higher stealth taxes, and perhaps make municipals a little less an attractive alternative.

James Colby, portfolio manager and senior municipal strategist at Market Vectors ETFs in New York. Market Vectors has six municipal bond ETFs with more than $2 billion in assets under management.

Login to your account

Email address:
Password:

Become a member

Register for a MunicipalBonds.com account to get access to a whole new way of tracking, analyzing, and researching bonds.

   Keep track of bonds you own
   Get ratings from S&P for all rated municipal bonds
   View issue history reports
   Access our price archives
...And much more

Register now »

We are providing certain data supplied to us by the Municipal Securities Rulemaking Board ("the Service") without warranties or representations and on an "as-is" basis. WE HEREBY DISCLAIM ALL REPRESENTATIONS AND WARRANTIES (EXPRESS OR IMPLIED), BUT NOT LIMITED TO, WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE REGARDING THE SERVICE. You shall bear all risk, related costs and liability and be responsible for your use of the Service.

The transaction data provided through the Real-Time Transaction Subscription Service represents municipal securities transaction data made available by brokers, dealers, and municipal securities dealers to the MSRB and related information. Such transaction data and/or related information may not exist for all municipal securities and may not be required to be submitted to the MSRB for certain types of municipal securities transactions. The MSRB does not review transaction data submitted by submitters for accuracy, completeness or any other purpose, and does not warrant or guarantee the accuracy of any such transaction data and/or related information.

The MSRB, its officers, directors, employees, agents, consultants, and licensors shall not be liable or responsible to you or anyone else for any losses, injuries, damages, costs, expenses or claims caused by, arising out of or relating to the following: (a) acts, omissions, occurrences or contingencies beyond their control; (b) service interruptions or performance failures, such as those that result from the use of telecommunications facilities that are outside of their control, including the Internet: (c) negligence, gross negligence or willful misconduct in procuring, compiling, interpreting, editing, writing, reporting or delivering any of the content and material; (d) lost, stolen, late, corrupted, misdirected, failed, incomplete or delayed transmissions by anyone using the Service, including, but not limited to, any technical malfunctions, human error, computer viruses, lost data transmissions, omissions, interruptions, deletions, defects, hyperlink failures or line failures of any telephone network, computer equipment, software or any combination thereof; (e) damage to your computer systems, equipment, software, data or other tangible or intangible property resulting from or sustained in connection with your use of the Service; and/or (f) any disruption of business, lost sales or lost profits or any punitive, exemplary, indirect, special, incidental, or consequential damages associated or in connection with, resulting from or arising out of any use of the Service or the content and material in the Service.

The MSRB and its officers, directors, employees, agents, consultants, and licensors shall have no liability in tort, contract, or otherwise (and as permitted by law, product liability) to you or anyone else for any reason associated or in connection with, resulting from or arising out of your use of the Service. The MSRB, its officers, directors, employees, agents, consultants, and licensors make, and have made, no recommendations regarding any of the securities or other investment vehicles, referred to or described in the Service.

The Service is reproduced by permission of the MSRB under a non-exclusive license. The MSRB accepts no responsibility for the accuracy of the reproduction of the Service or that Service is current.